PDA

View Full Version : Benefits cheat claimed £13,000


Trevortt
16-10-2007, 07:03 PM
A woman claimed more than £13,000 in benefits without revealing she had thousands of pounds of her own in two bank accounts, a court heard.

The five-year scam netted Karen Hird a total of £12,002 in housing benefit and £1,794 in Council Tax relief, Bradford Crown Court was told. Hird, 39, of Upper Seymour Street, Barkerend, Bradford, pleaded guilty to four charges of dishonestly claiming benefit by failing to declare savings and capital.

She was placed under a 12-month community order including 180 hours' unpaid work for the community, and will also have to pay £1,833 costs.

Passing sentence, Recorder Felicity Davies said the offences amounted to "thorough and persistent misconduct" over a considerable period of time.

"This was sustained dishonesty," she added. "Many other claimants would be astonished at the thought of you making these claims when you had got £30,000 in the bank." Freddy Apfel, prosecuting, said the false claims were made between September 2000 and December 2005.

Hird filled in application forms stating that she had a NatWest bank account, but failed to reveal she also had two accounts with the Halifax.

One of those had a balance of £30,000 in it at the time of the last offence.
Louise Azmi, mitigating, said Hird was ashamed of what she had done and the conviction would cause her problems in gaining employment in the future.



Yeh, nice damn punishment she got, 12-month community order including 180 hours' unpaid work for the community, and will also have to pay £1,833 costs, so she steals £13K but only has to pay back £1,833 leaving an O/S balance of £11,167 which i presume she can spend all to her self!! marvelous why don't we all do it.

Source (http://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/newsindex/display.var.1763762.0.benefits_cheat_claimed_13_00 0.php)

Greg Lance-Watkins
17-10-2007, 03:16 AM
Hi,

is there not a well established prescedent for this.

Did not the phillanderer who sired Cherrie Booth similarly claim and receive benefit from the state whilst holding substantial sums in at least one off shore banking account?

Regards,
Greg L-W.

ranger121
19-10-2007, 01:32 PM
Whilst the act of obtaining benefit by deception is abhorrent, the State will of course take reasonable action to recover the money overpaid to her. There is also no public advantage in locking the woman up.She hasn't been "let off" the thirteen grand, it's that the State can't get at it whilst it's in an overseas account.She has a choice, either she keeps her money overseas and lives off whatever interest that she can get, (in which case the State doesn't have to keep her whilst she's unemployed) or she brings it back to the UK where the State can recover the overpaid benefit from it. Either way, the taxpayer benefits.


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.2.0