View RSS Feed

Dr The Evidence's Political Blog (with Pop-Culture references)

DEPARTURE BLOG: Do you believe in Astrology?

Rate this Entry
by
DTE
on 26-01-2010 at 06:52 PM (205 Views)


I know I shouldn't. I know its stupid. I know most right-minded, rational people think its all rubbish. But still I find myself devoting time to it. Its wrong. Its a waste of time...

But enough about Celebrity Big Brother, this blog is about Astrology. The belief that "truth" (inverted commas signifying the subjective nature of said truth) can be found in star patterns, celestial bodies and that the position of the unvierse at the moment of your birth effects the type of person you become.

Now maybe you dismiss this as a load of superstitious nonsense, but the fact remains you probably know someone who believes, or at least knows a bit about it. They probably wear beads and are vegetarian. Maybe they smell faintly of hemp, I don't know. Regardless, everyone knows their star sign, and most people will identify certain characteristics that are common within themselves and others of their 'sign'. For example, Capricorns like myself, are said to be clumsy (check), goal orientated (partial check) and sometimes overly sarcastic (double check). There are common traits associated with other signs too, as I'm sure many of us will have heard said hippy friend of ours describe a person as a "typical libra" or some such.

Now I consider myself a rational person. I don't believe in ghosts or miracles and the subject of God causes me to scratch my head as I sit on the sceptic fence. But maybe there is something to this astrology stuff. I mean considering our place in the universe, and both the amazingly small portion of time and space we can hope to occupy in our lives, perhaps the allignment of stars, planets and galaxies at the moment we begin life does have some significance. It is our closest link with what comprises the 'rest' of the universe, is it not? And if all matter was created at the birth of a star, then surely THEY are the only truly creative forces in existence? If the universe is mostly space, stars and planets, then maybe the composition of those things affect who we are on some fundemental, basic level? As Moby said "We are all made of stars".

Yes, thats right. I just quoted Moby. Deal with it.

Ok so this is a strange story. It is slightly relevant though. When I was at school we had a assignment one day to write down any recurring dreams we might have. (Weird lesson I agree, but it was a catholic primary, so we had Double Guilt in the afternoon to make up for it.) I wrote down mine, involving me on a multi-lane, super wide motorway (or freeway, you Yanks), standing there on this vast deserted road, as suddenly a wall of traffic makes its way towards me. I turn to run, but can only do so in slow motion. They catch up quickly as I struggle to move. Then one of the cars hits and BANG, I'm awake.

Odd? Yes.

Signifier of some deep routed psychosis? Possibly.

But the strange thing is, there was this girl in my class who wrote down the same thing. Not just near, almost EXACT. To the word. So much so, the teacher thought we'd copied eachother. And what did her and I have in common?

Same birthday. In fact we were born in the same hospital.

Is that odd? Well for me and her it was. Does it have any greater significance? I'm not sure. But when thinking of astrology, I always come back to that memory. Because its weird. In my mind, either our star signs were the cause of such subconscious syncronicity, or the staff at Dudley Road Hospital were experimenting on newborn babies. I know which once I'd prefer to believe. Or of course its all just a coincidence, and I have been told its quite a common dream.

But I digress. As I often do.

The point is, not so much the back-of-the-newspaper horoscopes that say things like "tommorrow you will eat and talk", but what about the underlying belief, the cosmic ordering, does that have any real value? Any worth?

Back in the olden times, when people wore rags and kept warm by campfire and Snickers bars were called Marathon, and there was no such thing as "health and safety legislation" us human beings looked to the world around us to explain our existence. The Sun god, the bringer of rain, creator of mountains and valleys etc. As we venture out into the stars, and our understanding of the universe increases, will we look further afield to satisfy our yearnings for "truth" (theres that word again) or will our newfound knowledge replace the need for a God at all? If so, maybe we'll return to the stars, galaxies and planets, as an answer for our divine questioning.

What do you, faithful reader, think?

One thing is for sure, despite what the future brings...tomorrow we will eat and talk.

Submit "DEPARTURE BLOG: Do you believe in Astrology?" to Digg Submit "DEPARTURE BLOG: Do you believe in Astrology?" to del.icio.us Submit "DEPARTURE BLOG: Do you believe in Astrology?" to StumbleUpon Submit "DEPARTURE BLOG: Do you believe in Astrology?" to Google Submit "DEPARTURE BLOG: Do you believe in Astrology?" to Yahoo Submit "DEPARTURE BLOG: Do you believe in Astrology?" to FaceBook Share

Updated 26-01-2010 at 10:05 PM by DTE

Categories
Uncategorized

Comments

  1. Midas -
    Midas's Avatar
    To quote from www.astrology-and-science.com :-

    "Take sets of birth charts jumbled up with descriptions of their owners. Can astrologers match charts to owners? In astrology books they do it all the time. So we expect the proportion of successful matches to pile up close to 100%. To date a total of 54 studies have made this test using a total of 742 astrologers and 1407 birth charts. Despite these impressive numbers the average success rate was no different from the 50% expected by chance, see figure below. For these astrologers (many of them among the world's best) astrology performed no better than tossing a coin.


    Astrologers fail to match charts to owners better than chance

    Here the results expected by chance were determined by picking matches at random for each of the 54 studies and repeating 10,000 times. The difference between the 51.7% success rate achieved by astrologers and the 50.0% expected by chance is easily explained by the tendency of journals to accept positive results and reject negative results, and is in any case not even weakly significant (p=0.77)."

    In other words, astrology is a load of ****, and as with so many superstitions, people will simply believe what they want to believe regardless of how much evidence against it there might be. But I guess if you enjoy the entertainment value of it and don't take it remotely seriously, it does little harm.
    • |
    • permalink
  2. Janus -
    Janus's Avatar
    I think there is enough evidence to say that the supernatural overlaps and sometimes affects our world, and this is weighed against the doubt or unbelief of sceptics to a ratio of 50:50. I myself have had this evidence presented to me firsthand, although not with a blinding flash of realisation; it sometimes creeps up on you. Space does not allow me to explain here why I believe in the reality of the paranormal, but don't believe in astrology as such, but I have taken into consideration that what is perceived is often dependant upon the preconceived beliefs of the witness. As for astrology, are we not superior in intelligence to that to which we often submit our confidence? Burning spheres in outer space can have no more effect on our lives than the full moon can change someone into a werewolf. These are ancient traditions that go way back to when mathematicians and astronomers first learnt how to calculate the times and seasons. If I was born prematurely 2 months earlier I would have a different star sign but I would still be the same person at birth, wouldn't I? Also, there are as many personalities as there are people, but only 12 star signs to divide them among. It is also misleading to say that a Saggitarian makes friends more easily with an Arian than a Taurean before they test the water themselves with such people. These are the main reasons I don't believe in the stars, but I can appreciate that during major events the planets might be aligned in a specific way to help us determine the times and the ages. But on an individual level, I think to a greater extent than the influence the planets have over our lives we are masters of our own destinies, not pre-programmed robots who are unable to make rational decisions without a guide. Guidance is good, but I would put very little confidence in the stars for mine.
    • |
    • permalink

Trackbacks

Total Trackbacks 0
Trackback URL:


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.5.0 RC2

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115